FireStar01 posted a comment on Tuesday 27th November 2012 9:08am for Rosie's Plan

Wonderful story and so much better than Cannon. It gives a realiztic alternative. I enjoyed it a lot. Thank you for sharing.

Fire

Lathena posted a comment on Sunday 25th November 2012 8:14pm for Rosie's Plan

awesome fic!

Princess Fictoria posted a comment on Sunday 28th October 2012 11:25pm for Rosie's Plan

I re-read this story yet again and love it still. It is because of the quality of fandom writers, such as yourself, that has kept my love of potter verse fan fiction alive. Thank you for all of your hard work, and I hope you become inspired to delight us anew with another story... Thanks again!

drewbt63 posted a comment on Sunday 21st October 2012 7:10am for Rosie's Plan

This is a great tale, one of the best adaptations of Harry Potter I have read so far. the descriptions of why the story varied from the 'true story' is insightful.

I thought the ending scenario was perfect as Rose was the only person in Harry's life that he had a connection to that was not from his past, and therefore the curse would have no effect on their interactions

This would mean that she was probably the only one who could help Harry side step the curse.

In the words of Ron "brilliant"

Patches posted a comment on Sunday 14th October 2012 5:35am for Rosie's Plan

This is a great ending to a great story. I love the author notes that talked about what love truly is. You described it perfectly using the quotes from the Bible and your own paraphrased statements that were great examples. The way that Hermione and Harry got back together was fantastic. The fact it didn't all come rusing back was very well done and much more believeable. Your thoughtful comments about people that lose their loved ones slowly and painfully through Alzheimer's was very touching. Thanks for writing another great story. I look forward to whatever you come up with next time. pms

GBTtown posted a comment on Saturday 13th October 2012 7:45am for Rosie's Plan

It may be shorter than the last three books, but I like your magnum opus much more. I was really afraid that you were ending the story with the previous chapter. This was the right ending. (But please go wash your mouth out with soap... er maybe just wash the hand that wrote Albus Severus! Yech!) Great story. Definitely a fav if I knew how to mark such on this forum.

epsilon posted a comment on Saturday 13th October 2012 5:16am for Rosie's Plan

A great story. Thanks for sharing.

Silly_Billy posted a comment on Saturday 13th October 2012 1:50am for Rosie's Plan

Sorry,

I just re-read that and Jamie is her OLDEST sibling.

Well...don't I feel foolish!

Still - great story.

Silly_Billy posted a comment on Saturday 13th October 2012 1:47am for Rosie's Plan

HI,

Great story, I really liked the whole idea. Thank you for your time and effort.

Just one thing thoug. In the ending A/N you say "Rose is 16 years older than her youngest sibling".

BUT she started at Hogwarts when Hermione was "four-months-pregnant-and-just-starting-to-show"

Therefore even with the 'Twelve years later' epilogue, Jamie is only 11 years old, so that makes Rose a maximum 12 years older than Jamie - her youngest sibling.

Sorry to be pedantic, but it's what I do.