Fic Chick posted a comment on Monday 3rd April 2017 7:05am

I liked this.

tcl7189 posted a comment on Tuesday 7th October 2014 9:51pm

Great story!!

Kanzid posted a comment on Friday 14th December 2012 1:32pm

With the ease of taking out all the death eaters, and poking fun at clichés all over the place the story ends up coming across as fairly boring and generic with a lack of challenge or conflict. I find this to be a pity as your basic writing abilities are excellent, oh well.

Nytefyre posted a comment on Thursday 13th December 2012 11:46pm

Nice ending.

Tenchifew posted a comment on Thursday 13th December 2012 2:56pm

Very nice story.

Thank you for writing it.

Pennywise posted a comment on Thursday 13th December 2012 9:04am

Awesome ending to an awesome story.

lwj2 posted a comment on Thursday 13th December 2012 7:51am

Nicely done, sir. Your premise held up well and was actually logical -- not surprising, considering what you do for a living.

I've enjoyed reading this, thanks for writing and sharing it.

Best wishes for the holiday season and new year, thanks for the early present.

Patches posted a comment on Thursday 13th December 2012 3:22am

This is a great ending. Harry didn't have to fight Voldemort afterall. I'm glad Dumbledore sealed Voldemort in Azkaban before he died. That is a fitting end to Voldemort. He wanted to live forever. It will probably feel that way before his life ends. Very well done Thanks for all of your great stories. I have enjoyed everyone. I hope to see you write something else about Harry Potter and Hermione sometime. pms

Richard6154 posted a comment on Thursday 13th December 2012 2:09am

Whoot!

Another excellent story, thanks for sharing :)

chuckmcdaniels posted a comment on Thursday 13th December 2012 12:14am

Excellent ending to the story. I suppose I would have liked more detail around their year in Australia & the friends they made there, but then it is nice to just imagine how that may have gone. We also never hear more about Ron & co., though you deal with that quite well. And, interestingly enough, there *isn't* a final confrontation between Harry & Voldemort. Thanks for sharing your talents, and I hope we haven't seen the last of you!

noylj posted a comment on Tuesday 11th December 2012 9:07pm

Some day an update will come.

Thanks for writing.

Nytefyre posted a comment on Tuesday 11th December 2012 8:34pm

I've been enjoying re-reading these as you post them here. Thanks!

chuckmcdaniels posted a comment on Tuesday 11th December 2012 5:17pm

Thanks for another well-thought-out and fun to read chapter! I'm glad to hear that we do check in from time to time with the folks at Hogwarts, and I imagine there will be more cross-over of the story line to include that later, correct? Can't wait for the next installment.

Patches posted a comment on Tuesday 11th December 2012 3:21am

Well Australia was very interesting but the good stuff seems to happen on black Island. At least some of it does. I like the way things are working out. Sirius has a love interest that wants his child. I assume Sirius is happy. Harry and Hermione are going to try school at the AAMA. Hermione is happy she has new books to explore. Harry is happy to explore Hermione and the Grangers are happy together. I look forward to more of this story. I hope they find an Aborigini that can clear Harry's curse scar. Thanks for writing. pms

Patches posted a comment on Tuesday 11th December 2012 2:47am

This is a really different view of the Black Island. I seen it in several stories and I like them all. This is now one of my favorites. The different situations Harry and Hermione got into were fun. The French girls teaching Hermione a tan spell was great. The teens seeing a different attitude in Hermione's parents was fun and eye opening to the teens. Sirius hads another attitude and sense of fun along with it. I can see Sirius wanting to stay on the island forever. Especially since he has developed a relationship with one of the island women. It makes sense that Hermione would like to go back to school and the Grangers would probably like to see Australia. Thanks for writing. I look forward to more of this story. pms

Trixtor posted a comment on Monday 10th December 2012 11:55pm

That's a rather shallow view of the "eancipated minor." The term is not oxymoronic, as age does not necessarily coincide with freedom: the term indicates an exception (i.e. that this minor is emancipated.)

The usage isn't always due to impatience: it can be logically performed due to exploitation of a legal loophole (because logical paradoxes don't correspond to legislation: the "you must be 17 to enter, and you must enter, therefore you must be 17" is circular logic but absolutely true legally [as far as I'm aware,]) then used to place a stronger (take the term as you will,) Harry in a situation from the earlier books. It's not impatience.

Don't be so dismissive.

noylj posted a comment on Monday 10th December 2012 10:42pm

Great story. Why aren't they at school? Are they skipping a year?

Any updates would be appreciated.

chuckmcdaniels posted a comment on Monday 10th December 2012 5:49pm

Really enjoyed the detailed descriptions of both their environment and those pareos! I was wondering how much we would hear about things at Hogwarts. I guess it will be limited to just the occasional letter? I don't suppose they might return there at some point (for a visit)? Looking forward to the next installment!

Tenchifew posted a comment on Sunday 9th December 2012 8:38am

Very interesting and well written story.

Thank you for writing.

Pennywise posted a comment on Sunday 9th December 2012 8:32am

Awesome chapter.